Dietetics in India
This article briefly explains the present health situation in India, status
of Nutrition and Dietetics field; history of Dietetics in India; formation
of Indian Dietetic Association; role of Dietitians and Nutritionists in
India; and qualifications and requirements to become a nutrition professional.
It also explains why Dietetics field is still not recognized as an important
health service in India
.
Introduction:
India is the world's second most populated country with over 1 billion people
and is undergoing rapid economic transition. It is burdened by both communicable
and non-communicable diseases. It faces the major public health problems
like malnutrition as well as obesity, coronary heart diseases, diabetes,
cancer, and AIDS.
Diet and nutrition, along with lifestyle changes, are recognised as the
principal environmental components that create a wide range of diseases
throughout the country. In India, caloric inadequacy and deficiency diseases
continue to persist. They have been coexisting with the increasing presence
of diet-related chronic diseases. Diet, nutrition and changing lifestyles
are among the principal drivers of non-communicable diseases in developing
societies. Poverty and associated inequalities in societies, genetic or
ethnic variations in population groups also increase the vulnerability to
chronic diseases.
The feasibility of better clinical management of several diseases through
appropriate dietary control has always rendered diet therapy as a subject
of great importance to medical practitioners and the general public alike.
Dietitians and nutritionists are an important component of the health care
team and intervene with medical nutrition therapy in many serious illnesses.
But in India, the Dietitics field is still struggling to gain importance
between other allied medical and health practices.
Health Situation in India
Malnutrition poses a continuing constraint to India's development. Despite
improvements in health and well-being, malnutrition remains a silent emergency
in India. One of the main reasons for hunger and malnutrition in rural India
is lacking access to good food, water, transport, land and employment opportunities
for rural landless people. Still, the vast majority (over 65%) of the Indian
people lives in the rural areas with far more than a third living below
the poverty line and is threatened by hunger and malnutrition. One of the
most popular myths prevalent in Indian society is that only poor people
are afflicted with malnutrition. But many statistical studies show that
malnutrition occurs in all age groups and is distributed among people of
all income groups. In this situation, food, but lack of awareness about
proper intake of food, particularly rich in nutrients, is one of the prime
causes of malnutrition. It is true that overeating and improper diet can
also cause malnutrition. The World Bank estimates that malnutrition costs
India at least US$10 billion annually in terms of lost productivity, illness,
and death and is seriously retarding improvements in human development.
Prof. Ganguly (1) said, as per World Health Organization, estimates there
is 23 million diabetics in India today and this number would raise to 57
million by 2025 A.D. giving the country the dubious distinction of having
the largest number of diabetics in the world. This alarming increase is
expected to occur because of increased life expectancy, rapid urbanization
and changing lifestyles, especially related to diet and lack of exercise,
in addition to the unchecked population growth rate of 1.7 percent per year.
Estimates say that by 2025, one in every five diabetic persons in the world
will be an Indian.
In the last forty years heart disease incidence in the country witnessed
more than a four-fold increase and it is projected that 50 per cent of deaths
owing to cardiac ailment would be from India alone by 2015," said Dr.
Ashok Seth (2), the chief of invasive and interventional cardiology at Escorts
Heart Institute and Research Center, New Delhi. The prevalence of ischaemic
heart diseases amongst Indians is very high and ranges between 7 to 12 per
cent amongst adults in urban areas. By year 2020, India will have more patients
affected by heart attacks and angina than any other country in the world.
Heart attacks and angina among Indians occur early, relatively at a young
age, and is more severe and extensive.
India now has the second largest HIV-positive population in the world behind
South Africa, which has 5 million reported infections in a population of
42 million. According to India's National AIDS Control Organization, the
number of AIDS cases reported to health authorities jumped more than 15
percent to 4.58 million infections in one year, the most dramatic increase
the country has yet seen (3).
India has about 800,000 cancer patients at present and their number has
been constantly increasing due to rising disease (4). There is a constant
rise in the number of prostrate, oesophagus, head, neck and breast cancers
along with an alarming increase in leukaemia cases. Sadly, none were able
to quantify them as there has been no nation-wide survey of the same. The
majority of cancer cases among men were head and neck cancer while in women
cancer of cervix and breast were the most common.
In India the number of overweight people has increased significantly over the last ten years. Even by conservative estimates, five per cent of the total population in the country is believed to be overweight. It is widely acknowledged that obese persons are at a greater risk of having diabetes, high blood pressure, coronary artery disease, and even arthritis (5). The problem of obesity is fast spreading in India with almost a third of middle class men and half its' women falling prey to this lifestyle anomaly according to Dr. P.S.Chatterjee, professor in the School of Tropical Medicine's Department of Nutrition and Metabolic diseases (presentation on Ideal Body Weight -- How to Achieve?' on Dec 6th 2003). Quoting recent survey findings, he said 32 per cent of Indian adults in the high socio-economic group were overweight while three per cent men and 14 per cent women above 40 years of age suffered from obesity, an anomaly that the WHO has placed in the list of the top 10 killers (6).
Over the past few years, the healthcare scene in the country has been witnessing
revolutionary developments. Nutrition, fitness and health are fast becoming
areas of key interests in Indian society. The recent interest in health and
fitness has resulted in mushrooming of health clinics and fitness centres
all over the country. Along with these, the increased life expectancy has
resulted in a growing and aging population that has increased the demand for
nutritional guidance and counselling in hospitals, nursing homes, community
health programs, schools, and door-to-door healthcare services in villages
as well as in cities. Among the top 30 occupations of 2001, half of them are
health-related.
The Bureau of Labor Statistics mentioned that, employment in the private hospital
industry is growing slowly. The number of health practitioners, nursing and
personal care staff, nutrition and dietetics specialists is expected to grow
faster than in most other occupations (7). Several job opportunities have
been coming up in the fields of nutrition and dietetics, rehabilitation units,
health and wellness clinics, family guidance and child-care centers and several
other counseling centers.
History of Dietetics in India.
The current nutrition and dietetic education in India differs from the United
States and other European countries. The field of Dietetics is very much advanced
in these developed countries. However, in such a big populated country like
India, the struggle for recognition of the dietary department services is
still going on. The dietetics filed has not gained much momentum in India
and unfortunately, it has been neglected by several health professionals for
a long period of time. As the complexity of the nutrition delivery system
grows, the expertise and numbers of leaders in nutrition will need to continue
as well. Experts within the country and within the culture will be challenged
in coming years to provide nutrition education for the growing population.
India's population is extremely diverse in language, color, religion, caste
and class and . consequently, in food habits. Culture is an essential part
of food behavior. India has a rich and diverse culture that represents a wide
array of health practices and beliefs. The food available in India is as diverse
as its culture, its racial structure, its geography and its climate. India
is a county where resources are precious and very little is wasted. Extensive
work has already been done in recognizing several nutritional problems related
to this diversity.
In India, one of the most disturbing and least satisfactory aspects of patient
care is dietary service. In the average hospital situation, its organization,
administration and sanitation has left much to the desired or expected. It
is a well-known fact to all that, Indian Dietaries need a great deal of change
to improve their services. A few hospitals in major cities have well- maintained,
organized, equipped and staffed dietary departments to provide food service
to the in-patients. Their service of food includes a number of function planning
menus, purchase of raw materials (as opposed to packaged) and distribution
of the prepared product to the patients. The physical facilities of the dietary
department have an important influence on the standard of food service, labor
charges and morale of workers. But most of the Indian hospitals are lacking
suitable equipment for efficient food production and service and unfortunately
many of them do not have a Dietary department at all. The present dietary
set up environment in Indian hospitals needs a great improvement in terms
of quality as well as quantity. In India, Vellore Dietitics department is
one of the oldest dietary departments in the country and now it is
Formation of Indian Dietetic Association
In 1963, a small group of nutritionists, dietitians and workers in the allied
health fields resolved to form a scientific body to highlight the importance
of dietetics and nutrition in the maintenance of health, and in the prevention
and treatment of diseases. Thus, the Indian Dietetic Association (IDA) was
founded, with Prof. Kalyan Bagchi as Secretary and Dr. C. Gopalan as President
(8). The aims and objectives of IDA are to promote the cause of science by
encouraging the spirit of active pursuit of knowledge and original scientific
research particularly in the field of Nutrition and Dietetics; to facilitate
social, scientific and cultural fellowship and cultivation of goodwill among
its members; to promote close contact and interaction between persons following
different branches and thus facilitate the development of a wider outlook
and the integration and application of available scientific knowledge for
the welfare of society and finally to safeguard the interests of scientists
generally and its members in particular and work for their welfare.
The IDA was affiliated to the International congress of Dietetics in 1975.
The IDA has its own registration board which became operational in Jan 1981.
The board consists of the current President of IDA and five other members
elected by executives. The main objective of the registration board is to
ensure minimum standards of teaching and training in dietetics and to maintain
a register of professional dietitians. It takes care of all the activities
related to registration of dietitians. The IDA started its own scientific
journal in 1963. It was named as "Journal of the Indian Dietetic Association".
The inaugural issue came out in December 1963 coinciding with the first Annual
Convention of the Association. It was re-christened as "Applied Nutrition"
in 1973 with two issues published every year. The journal has been renamed
as JIDA "Journal of the Indian Dietetic Association" in 2003.
Today there are approximately 3000 registered members in IDA all over India.
All these members may not necessarily be the practicing Dietitians and Nutritionists.
Due to lack of opportunities and support in the healthcare industries, many
qualified nutrition people are jumping over to the other fields. Even if they
are employed, their payment is less when compared to the other fields. The
dietitians who are employed in the hospitals are sometimes not given much
importance when compared to the doctors and their valuable services have been
ignored. Here comes the question of practical knowledge of dietitians. Many
dietitians complain that, they are not given the recognition that they deserve
and their role is only dedicated to supervise the hospital kitchen and to
passively supply the calories and proteins given by the physician. The physicians
defend that attitude. Another problem is that most of the dietitians do not
possess practical knowledge, which is vital in clinical nutrition applications.
The majority of the patients who visit the hospitals do not know about the
Dietetics department and its significance. People give less importance to
the dietary treatment when compared to medical treatment. During illness,
people usually follow some diet restrictions according to their grandmas'
or some other older person's advice since grandmas provide valuable, domestic,
cheap and best remedies. So, many people don't feel it as a necessary to consult
a dietitian when they are getting similar advices from their homes itself.
That is also one of the reasons why the Dietetics field has not been recognized
as an important subject. There is an old saying which is still followed by
almost all Indians is that "Fasting is the greatest medicine". So
many traditional Indian people do fasting for one day in a week. They feel
that it is the most appropriate remedy for indigestion, constipation, fevers
and several other illnesses.
It is an age-old practice that, doctors themselves counsel the patients regarding
their diets and prescribe therapeutic modifications. Even today also the same
situation is continued in many of the urban hospitals In India. To be frank,
Indians are well accustomed to the doctors' suggestions rather than dietitians'.
It is observed that, even well educated patients are also not utilizing the
valuable services of dietitians.
There are only approximately 300 Registered Dietitians (RDs) in India, which
really depicts the lack of importance of RDs in hospitals and healthcare industries.
Only a few corporate hospitals in metropolitan cities are utilizing Registered
Dietitians' services in the country. The reasons for very less number of qualified
RDs may be due to several important factors. The RD qualification is not a
compulsory requirement in many hospitals. Even a graduate student, with or
without hospital work experience, is allowed to take part in critical clinical
nutrition aspects. Those who have RD qualification are moving to western countries
for better employment opportunities. The present IDA members (approx.3000)
is also fewer when compared to USA figures. There are approximately 70,000
members registered with American Dietetic Association (ADA), which is the
nation's largest Organization for food and nutrition professionals (9). Approximately
75 percent of ADA's members are registered dietitians (RDs).
One of the biggest challenges facing the dietetic profession in India is the
development and operation of quality nutrition services in the evolving healthcare
systems. The present strength of dietitians and nutritionists is not at all
sufficient to the unchecked Indian population. During IDA's 13th Convention
in 1978, President Dr. C.V.Ramakrishnan stressed that all the state Governments
as well as private hospitals and nursing homes should develop dietetic departments
as per the recommendations of the Government of India Committee on Standardized
diets for hospitals. The committee had recommended that every hospital having
100 to 300 beds should have one dietitian and 300 to 600 beds two dietitians,
with adequate provision for a dietary department (10). Unfortunately, this
recommendation had not been fully followed in most of the Indian hospitals.
Even in those places, dietitians act more or less like a store clerk or just
a kitchen supervisor.
Now there are thousands of hospitals and medical centers in India. Most hospitals
have large open wards with minimal staff. The number of hospitals and bed
capacity in India has doubled in last ten years. There are approximately 11,174
hospitals out of which 57 percent are in the private sector. The total number
of beds are expected to grow from 1500,000 (2001) to 2250,000 (2012) and the
Indian Govt. is spending 17,000 Crores on Healthcare and Private Industry
spends 69,000 Crores (11). Food service is very informal and bulk oriented
in composition. Therapeutic diets are difficult to enforce within the hospital
and almost impossible to enforce as an outpatient due to lack of specialty
foods and economic issues. India does not even meet 1/3rd of Healthcare Standards
set by WHO. So the available number of dietitians is not at all proportionate
to the growing number of beds in Indian hospitals and there is an immediate
requirement to absorb the dietitians.
India has several centers of nutrition interest. The Nutrition Foundation
of India (NFI) is a non-governmental voluntary agency dedicated to the upliftment
of the nutrition status of Indians. It plays a catalytic role of advocacy
and education to focus attention on major nutritional problems; provides leads
for practical action in overcoming these problems; and combats inadequacies
in the implementation of ongoing nutrition programs.
The Nutrition Society of India (NSI), a professional organization, holds annual
academic sessions to share information and research. The National Institute
of Nutrition (NIN) at Hyderabad is one of the premier permanent research Institutes
of the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR), an autonomous body under
the aegis of the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India.
The history of this Institute spans over eight decades. It has published periodic
editions of Nutritive Value of Indian Foods. This center also trains dietitians
in India. (12)
Role of Nutritionists and Dietitians in India today.
Dietetics has yet to find its rightful place in Indian therapeutics. Nutritionists
and dieticians are an integral part of the health care services. A majority
of even our teaching hospitals do not have qualified dietitians. An important
factor which, has probably contributed to the rather unsatisfactory position
accorded to dietetics in India today, is the lack of authoritative information
useful to doctors and nurses in the prescription of suitable therapeutic diets.
Since no two human beings are alike, the dietician's job can be quite varied
and interesting. It's always a challenge to figure out a specific diet plan
based on the doctor's diagnosis and the patient's condition and lifestyle.
The major role of dietitians in India is to assist people in planning their
meals depending upon their age, sickness or work routine. Dieticians scientifically
evaluate diet need of a client and suggest diet modifications. The dietitian
is a specialist who interprets the physician's orders in terms of daily meal
patterns that have been individualized according to the patient's food habits
as well as modified according to the patient's therapeutic needs. He/She is
responsible for the preparation and service of food to the patient, the evaluation
of patient's response to the diet and subsequent counselling of the patient
and his family. The nutritionists counsel individuals and groups, organize
the food service systems in hospitals, schools, hotels etc.
Dietitians specialize in education, research, administration and clinical/community dietetics. Administrative dietitians play a major role in large-scale meal planning and monitoring the food preparation process in schools, canteens etc. They take up the entire responsibility of their department and actively participate in selection, training, budgeting, equipment purchase, checking safety regulations, maintaining records etc. Clinical dietitians are associated with health care institutes, hospitals and nursing homes. Depending on the nutrition needs of the patients, they prepare their diet charts and monitor the results of dietary therapy. The other category of Dietitians belongs to Research and Development. These Research Dietitians work in the field of nutrition in healthy and therapeutic food items. They work in studying the effects of various types of diets on the body chemistry. They are also involved in conducting highly specialized research in nutritional needs of chronic disease patients and special people like astronauts.
Dieticians can guide all kinds of patients and clients regarding their healthy
eating habits and draw up personalized food plans that coincide with their
dietary restrictions, occupational constraints, fitness and stress levels,
etc. They help them choose more appropriate foods. The diets they provide
have therapeutic value and are worked out for each patient according to the
illness. Other than planning meals, dieticians also look into the day-to-day
functioning of the organization for which they work. The nutritionist, on
the other hand, studies the effect of food (on humans) and the effect on food
(when it is cooked/served). A nutritionist's work mostly consists of preventing
illnesses and rehabilitating patients after an illness. But, dietary counseling
and satisfaction of the nutritional needs of the patient requires the coordination
of medical, nursing and dietary staff. The importance of the dietitian is
well depicted in the following picture.
The common goal in feeding patients in Indian hospitals is to provide quality food that meets nutritional standards at the most economical cost. But this goal is not being achieved by many hospital dietary departments since hospital food services pose a special situation. They have captive patrons, built-in-food restrictions and a definite type of service. They cater to patients of all ages from all walks of life with different life-styles, food habits, and cultural and social preferences. Thus food service to the patients requires a lot of imagination and ingenuity in planning for a variety of foods that meet the needs of the patients. Dietitians and nutritionists, who are associated with hospitals and clinics generally, have regular work hours. In this environment, they come in direct contact with patients and advise them appropriate diet based on the illness. In commercial food service, the working hours are usually irregular.
Qualifications and Requirements to become a Dietitian or a Nutritionist
in India.
Educational Qualification: A dietitian should preferably complete M.Sc
(Nutrition), which is a 2year course after graduation. Preferable fields
of graduation are - Microbiology, Chemistry, Home Science, Medicine, Hotel
management or catering technology. Other option is to pursue a 1year PG
Diploma in Nutrition and Dietetics. Fresh dietitians usually undergo training
for 1 year in the Dietetics department of the hospital.
A number of universities offer a 3-yr BSc in nutrition/ dietetics / food
technology. Both Delhi University and Bombay University also have a BA
with nutrition and health education course. Delhi University's BA in food
technology is available in five women's colleges - Aditi Mahila Mahavidyalaya,
Bhagini Nivedita College, Lakshimibai College for Women, and Vivekananda
College. The BA course in nutrition and health education is offered at
Aditi Mahila Mahavidyalaya, Bhagini Nivedita College and Daulat Ram. Food
and nutrition is offered as a specialization in MSc home science courses
at over 45 universities. While some like the University of Delhi, require
BSc (home science), others like the MS University of Baroda, also admit
students with BSc in related subjects.
Curriculum: The curriculum is a mix of biological, social and food-based
skills. It includes study of biological basis of health, food and culture,
investigative skills, cell biology and metabolism, sociology, psychology,
nutrition in health, therapeutic nutrition, advanced nutrition, clinical
nutrition, community nutrition, food science, human physiology, microbiology
and immunology and biological basis of disease.
Salary: In hospitals, trainees generally receive a starting salary of
Rs 3,000 (approx.$65) per month, which may go up (after three months of
service) to about Rs 5,000 to Rs 8,000. Nutritionists, quality control
managers and dieticians are in great demand and the pay depends on the
organization you are working for - it generally hovers in the range of
Rs 12,000/- per month.
How to become a Registered Dietitian in India?
To become a Registered Dietitian, one must meet the eligibility requirements
set by IDA and pass the RD exam conducted every year by the Chairperson,
Vellore. The eligibility Requirements for R.D. Examinations includes:
1. Life membership in IDA. 2. Graduate in Nutrition and Dietetics / P.G.
Diploma or Master's degree in Nutrition and Dietetics. 3. Six months Internship
after completion of qualifying exam in a multi specialty hospital recognized
by IDA for internship & supervised by an R.D. The internship should
be done continuously or in two installments of 2-4 months each, with a
break of not more than 6 weeks. The internship should be completed by
the 31st of August every year. OR Two years of experience as a full time
dietitian in a multi specialty hospital (13).
Other possible opportunities for Nutrition/Dietetics professionals:
Apart from Nutrition and Dietetic jobs, there are good career opportunities in the food industry too. Lot of food companies employs nutritionists and dietitians to check the nutritional quality of the food products, for new product development and for marketing related advice. There is teamwork involved in experimenting on flavors and preparations. This along with the booming commercial food services will ensure that these professionals continue to have ample job opportunities in the future. Research Institutions, Hospitals, Pharmaceutical Firms, Food Manufacturing Companies, Fitness Clubs and Clinics and large canteens are some of the places offering attractive openings to these professionals. With increasing health concerns amongst the population at large and a growing awareness about fitness and preventive care, writing on health and nutrition and suggesting innovative recipes with a focus on healthy and balanced eating, can be a good occupation if you have a flair for writing. All nutrition professionals can work as freelance writers for magazines, books, newspapers etc. and can share their knowledge in educating the people.
Summary
The government has to recognize the need for dietary department in all hospitals and its valuable services to the patients and must see that dietary services are mandatory along with other healthcare services. There is a definite need to understand the importance and utility of the dietary department staffed by well-trained personnel, with suitable remuneration so as to encourage, improve and uphold high standards in the preparation and services of clean, wholesome food to all types of patients in every hospital or nursing home. Educational institutes like colleges and universities need to start advanced Nutrition education courses to produce qualified Dietetics professionals. All teaching hospitals are required to provide quality internship experience to the budding professionals. The government has to provide good infrastructure facilities for planning, preparing and servicing of food items to the patients. Students must be encouraged to study Dietetics with good accommodation, stipend, certification, recognition and placements. Indian Dietetic Association must take this responsibility of producing more number of qualified dietitians and nutritionists to serve the patients and public.
References:
1. VIPs comments on MVDSC. (n.d). Retrieved on Dec 19 2003. http://www.mvdsc.org/main.cfm?page=experts
2. Ashok Seth. Super specialty hospitals put India on international map'.
Issue dated. 16th to 30th April 2003. Retrieved on 19 Dec 2003. http://www.expresshealthcaremgmt.com/20030430/profile.shtml
3. India's AIDS Cases Skyrocket, Nation Stands at Verge of Catastrophe.
(n.d.) Retrieved on 19 Dec 2003. http://www.worldvision.org/worldvision/pr.nsf/stable/update_india_080403
4. Early detection must for reducing cancer mortality: experts; Central
Chronicle. Sunday December 7, 2003. Retrieved on 20 Dec 2003. http://www.centralchronicle.com/20031207/0712144.htm
5. D Bansal and Ravneet Kaur Boparai, New Insights into Obesity. RESONANCE
December 2003. p.92-93. Retrieved on 20 Dec 2003. http://www.ias.ac.in/resonance/Dec2003/pdf/Dec2003Researchnews.pdf
6. P S Chatterjee. Obesity assuming menacing proportions in India: Experts.
Sunday, December 07, 2003. The Times of India. Retrieved on 20 Dec 2003.
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/344541.cms
7. Career Opportunities-Health Careers. (n.d). Retrieved on 20 Dec 2003.
http://www.careermosaicindia.com/cobrand/apollolife/caropp/Introduction.htm
8. About Us. Indian Dietetic Association. (n.d). Retrieved on 20 Dec 2003.
http://www.idaindia.com/aboutus.asp
9. Welcome. American Dietetic Association. (n.d). Retrieved on 19 Dec
03. http://www.eatright.org/Public/
10. Shantha and Mohan. Dietary Services in Hospitals. A Manual of Second
Regional Workshop on Planning Diet for Health. March 1999.p.12-15.
11. Instromedix India Pvt.Ltd. (n.d). Retrieved on Dec 19 2003. http://www.instromedixindia.com/market.htm
12. Judith A. Beto. Beneficial Nutrition Program Through International
Alliance With ADA or ICDA. 1994. Retrieved on Dec 19, 2003 http://www.eatright.org/Public/7772_17292.cfm
13. Registration. Indian Dietetic Association. (n.d). Retrieved on 19
Dec 2003. http://www.idaindia.com/Registration.asp?#app
Copyright Kathy Shattler 2004. This article may not be reproduced without
the express permission of this editor, K.J.Shattler at kshattler@chartermi.net
Questions may be directed to:
Dr. Aparna Sarna
Vinayak Infotech,
80/96, Nisha Anand Complex,
Chamiers Road,
Teynampet,
Chennai-18.
aparna@vinsinfo.com
vins_aparna@hotmail.com.