Schindler's List
Schindler's List is most popularly known as a film made by Steven
Spielberg. Before that, it was a book written by Thomas Keneally, who
incidentally is an Irishman. It describes a true story of the
dichotomous efforts of a German man who made enormous profits under the
Third Reich during the Second Great War. The man's name was Oskar
Schindler. In his efforts to accumulate Reichmarks, he happened to save
800+ souls, and their generations to follow.
I liken his efforts to the war on AIDS. I see parallels between
his efforts, and the present day efforts of those who argue, persuade,
and incessantly insist that what should be and what will be
in our world will amount to the salvation of human lives.
Schindler settled for no less.
I first saw Schindler's List in the theatre, back in soCal,
and I remember being disoriented when I exited the Costa Mesa theatre
parking lot - the film had such an impact on my mind. I wrote about it
in an earlier blog. This time, there
were fewer tears; I've developed a more rational mind. But there are
strong emotions that still are brought to bear with this film.
*
* * *
* *
In the midst of hell, an observant man
identified a way to make a lot of money. He played his pieces well, and
found himself in a position that proved to be...in current jargon...not
golden, but platinum. While making his millions, he came to appreciate
one of the expenses of the war - the dispensable lives of human cattle.
And in a gradual change of focus, he began to work toward saving those
lives under the guise of supporting the efforts of the 1940's Nazi war.
The film concludes with the result of Schindler's effort. More Schindler
Jews are alive today than the number that remained in Poland in 1944.
Now let me tie the emotions that are brought up by Schindler's List
with the emotions and the true struggles that are occurring every day in
AIDS-ravaged, impoverished areas of our world. In addition to that, I'd
like to present a more balanced view of the current Bush administration
with regard to foreign policy than I did when I chastised Bush for his
involvement in Iraq, in a different
previous blog. I still strongly disagree with US efforts in Iraq,
but I want to focus on the absolute good that the President's
Emergency Plan for AIDS Relieve (PEPFAR) is doing.
*
* * *
* *
BACKGROUND
In the midst of
circumstances that are largely out of their control, average sub-Saharan
Africans have found themselves in an impoverished state that has
resulted from, in large part, the exploitation of economic powers that
have discounted the value of African lives. I have only recently come to
think about the natural resources and lay of the land of the vast
continent of Africa. Mother Africa presents geographic barriers to
modern commerce that are perhaps higher than in any other temperate to
tropical part of our Earth. Land masses are over 5,000 Km long,
surrounded by oceans that separate Africa from other commercial nodes.
The Internet alleviates some of that, but limits to that include laying
the cable, so to speak, to make that Internet accessible. Natural
resource limitations have certainly played a part in the poverty that
persists in much of Africa, but I would say that a great deal of poverty
has been supported, whether inadvertently, by global economics that have
always dealt Africans a draw from the smaller deck of cards.
Enter three chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes troglodytes) that
zoonotically transmitted a virus to we humans. In several decades, we
have developed a viral epidemic that has killed more people than all of
the wars of the 20th and 21st centuries combined. Forty Million are
dead, and nearly that many infected right now.
And the number of new infections is rising each year. [FACT]
PEPFAR
In 2001, Bush's celebrated State of the Union Address announced a 15
Billlion dollar commitment toward the prevention and treatment of
HIV in countries that could demonstrate the infrastructure and
accountability necessary to sustain such an effort. Good Fortune placed
Zambia and UAB (The University of Alabama at Birmingham) in one of the
15 spotlights for this program.
Now, nearly five years later, HIV medications are available for free
to all who can overcome the stigma, distrust, and remaining economic
obstacles to obtaining treatment. For those who can understand the
benefit, and manage the access to care, they can live now to see their
grandchildren. This is a taken-for-granted notion that you and I expect,
but that in Zambia, where the average life expectancy is close to 40...that
is, not quite reaching 40...is
a gift of Life itself.
* * *
* * *
Now let me quote
from the film and make a few statements. When the time came to
exterminate the Polish Jews, Itszak Stern, who serves as Schindler's
accountant, remarks on the efforts of Schindler to provide their safety
by getting them preferential status when they are moved to 1944
Czechoslovakia.
"You're not buying them?" Stern asks.
"You would
convince me to not do it if you were wise. I'm losing too much money,"
Schindler replies.
After ledgering over 800 names, Stern says, "The
list is an absolute good. The list is Life," he says.
The point I
would like to make here is that here and now in the twenty-oughts, we can save 800 names - we can save 800
thousand names - we can save 800 million names, if you count the future
generations lost to AIDS - if we simply apply the
political and economic will to do so. We don't even have the evils of
war hanging over our heads while we make that decision. (At least we
Americans didn't until the post-9/11 invasion of Iraq took place.)
Is
it only a matter of money?
If it is, are we then prioritizing
profit-making over the lives of names of individuals who would otherwise
further generations of our Fellow Humankind?
Who are given the
right to live?
Who grants that right? Are we beholden to ensure
that preventable causes of death are just that...Prevented?
Is God or
Allah watching? Who is keeping score? Are we winning? Or are we focused
too much on ourselves?
I know that the Bible says that the greatest
commandment is to Love one another.
I also learned tonight that
the Jewish Talamut says that Whoever saves one life saves the
World entire.
I imagine that Islam says the same.
Yet here we
are.
For me personally, I've seen firsthand the unspeakable
devastation of HIV (a word combination I do not use lightly), and I find
that my personal mission is to improve the lives of those affected by
HIV. Moreover, I think it is wrong to do otherwise. That is not to say
that everyone's primary focus must be related to HIV. However, in the
era we live in, and with the successful medications we have, I do not
understand folks who do not support applying some of their efforts to
thwarting the most productive thief of human life-years we have seen in
the last 5,000 years of our brief Human history.
I am reminded of
these quotations from Schindler and Stern near the end of the film:
"I
didn't do enough", Schindler said.
Stern replied, "You did so much."
When the end of our days comes, and we look back on our efforts, what
will we think of ourselves? There will always be times of wastefulness
that highlight our regrets. Will we be able to balance those memories
with the lights of eyes that are shining still today because of some
good that has come from our works? Despite the greed and gluttony of
human nature, will the balance of our deeds tip in favor of Good?