May 9, 2002
Special Report: Trading Derek Jeter
DO YOU ACCEPT? ... Have you seen the terrific new tool
ESPN.com has offered to fantasy GMs called "Trades Accepted"?
It's a new link available from any individual Fantasy Player
Card which lists every approved trade involving that player in
all ESPN.com leagues. This is a fascinating new way to gauge
the value of a player you're considering acquiring or dealing
away. Let's take a look at what we can learn from this tool by
examining trades involving the most popular Yankee, shortstop
Derek Jeter.
Tearing it Up
JETER OF ALL TRADES ... In the past two weeks, Jeter has been
involved in 66 trades; for the purpose of accurate
comparisons, we'll only look at the 23 in which he was swapped
straight up for another player or for a package of players.
The package-for-package trades are harder to use in analyzing
an individual player's potential worth, but they can be
fascinating to review. And of course, this list of trades is
taken completely out of context; unlikely as it may be,
someone dealing Jeter might have both Garciaparra and Aurilia
and be freer to swap Jeter at low value to fill a need.
Slumping
FELIX FERMIN WASN'T AVAILABLE? ... There have been some, well,
wacky Jeter trades recently; one GM dealt the future Hall of
Famer straight up for Cristian Guzman -- and the trade wasn't
even protested. Consider that in two other leagues Jeter was
worth both Guzman and Tim Hudson and Guzman and Al Leiter, and
you get an idea of how lopsided that first one was. A third
deal brought home Leiter and Edgar Renteria -- who still has
name value, but who deserves his #17 ranking at shortstop in
the ESPN Player Rater.
At the Plate
TAKE ANOTHER (SALES) PITCH ... Jeter has been traded even-up
for the following position players, listed in order of current
value: Sammy Sosa, Andruw Jones and Rich Aurilia. Some
possible explanations ... The Sosa owner was either a blindly
loyal Yankees fan or bizarrely overloaded in the outfield and
weak in the infield ... The Jones owner needed help in batting
average and steals while the Jeter owner was in desperate need
of power ... The Aurilia owner conned a Giants fan.
Probable Starters
May 9: Hernandez @TB (Kennedy)
May 10: Wells @MIN (Milton)
May 11: Lilly @MIN (Lohse)
May 12: Mussina @MIN (Reed)
May 13: Off Day
|
From the Rubber
CLOSING THE DEAL ... Saves are so important in fantasy
baseball that Jeter has been traded straight up for Robb Nen,
John Smoltz, Trevor Hoffman -- and Danny Graves? He's also
been deemed fair price for two starting pitchers: AL wins
leader Mark Buehrle and Hall of Fame teammate Roger Clemens. A
separate deal for both Buehrle and hot-starting Shea
Hillenbrand, excellent on its own merits, pales in comparison
to one where Jeter brought Greg Maddux and NL saves leader
Mike Williams.
On the Mend
OUCH, MY TEAM HURTS ... Other Jeter trades were clearly
efforts to patch multiple lineup holes; the best of these was
probably for Jeff Kent and Frank Thomas, though depending on
need, the deal for Scott Rolen and Orlando Cabrera could work
well. Miguel Tejada was accompanied in one case by Derrek Lee
and another by Esteban Yan; neither of those looks promising
in the long run. Jeter-for-a-closer turned into Nen and Jose
Hernandez, Bob Wickman and Juan Uribe and Ugueth Urbina with
both Craig Counsell and Jacque Jones. Uribe's got potential,
but the deal of him and Livan Hernandez for Jeter was just
strange.
Recent Call-ups
LIKE DEBBY HARRY SANG BACK IN '80, CALL ME ... These columns,
updated weekly or as breaking news warrants, are archived at
http://dellepro.dellhost.com/doherty/sports/ESPN/ ... send
questions to RotoYanks@yahoo.com.